Early Christmas for BCS haters
Sunday, November 30th, 2008We know the Bowl Championship Series cannot determine a national championship. The system sacrificed Ohio State for the past two years and at least for one of the years, we knew it would happen.
This year, we at least get to see a new failure. We get to watch the system mess up a division in a conference. And I say this before we know whether Texas, Texas Tech or Oklahoma will represent the Big 12 South Division.
With three teams tied with one loss, the the highest-ranked team in the BCS will be the South champion. Texas beat Oklahoma, Texas Tech beat Texas and Oklahoma beat Texas Tech. All three won their games Saturday. If you can make an argument for any of the teams, Oklahoma has the toughest non-conference schedule - which includes a win over Big East champion Cincinnati. The Sooners - and as a Nebraska fan I can’t believe I am arguing this - also had the only convincing win in the games between the three schools, a blowout against Texas Tech. That win somehow - and I don’t agree with it - took Texas Tech completely out of the equation even though Tech had championship aspirations eight days ago. These reasons put the nation behind the Sooners.
Texas beat Oklahoma, right? (Dallas is not a neutral field)
No matter what the BCS decides, it will not be fair. We are ignoring the one fact that is relevant: Settling it on the field. Each team will say it defeated one of the other. Like the BCS title game, we will never know who the best team is because it is very possible that team will be watching the conference championship.
How do we settle it? Yep, a playoff. Either that or an old-fashioned coin toss (I’d take that over the BCS).
With three Big 12 teams in the top 10, mark this down. The BCS has messed up the national title picture before one conference championship game is played.
Every year we have the BCS, we learn of a way the system can mess up. Last year, a Big 10 sacrificial lamb for an overhyped SEC. Even in 2001, when Nebraska made the title game without playing in the conference championship game. You know something is wrong when your favorite team is in the national title game and you do not necessarily agree with it.
This year: A conference championship. Never has the playoff cheer been louder.
- Russo
