By Kevin Woster
NBC White House correspondent Chuck Todd has taken some criticism over his question last night to President Barack Obama:
Where’s the sacrifice?
Since this is the equivalent of a financial war, what are U.S. citizens being asked to sacrifice?
I think Todd asked a good question. It’s not quite as good as a similar question that President George W. Bush never answered during his White House tenure: Where’s the sacrifice for the Iraq and Afghanistan wars, beyond the one by those who are fighting it and their families?
Their sacrifices, of course, were huge. And the rest of us? Not so much.
What have we done as a nation overall to sacrifice for that war? Not even so much as a specific tax to pay for it.
Nothing was rationed. Nothing was denied. Nothing changed at all in our daily lives, except for the sadness we certainly felt at the loss of human lives and the growing economic toll.
Fighting the economic-recovery war is less serious in human terms, certainly, than the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. But still, shouldn’t citizens be asked to do something in the way of specific sacrifices?
Obama says Americans are already sacrificing, as they struggle to pay their mortgages and health-care bills, help kids pay tuition, manage increased costs of living on stagnant or declining salaries, or in the face of job layoffs.
Well, sure, yeah, there’s real pain there. But those aren’t really sacrifices FOR anything. They’re impacts FROM something.
What are we doing specicifically, as part of a recovery plan, to help right the tipping financial ship? Well, most of us are getting a tax break, albeit a small one. Many of us are going to get debt reduction, even if we were irresponsible in our borrowing practices and managing our wants versus our needs.
Many of us will get increased social benefits.
There will be more jobs, more government programs, more government dollars, more assistance for banks and financial groups, even if they, too, were irresponsible in their financial affairs.
The wealthy among us will sacrifice a bit, in a higher tax rate, and a lower deduction for charitable contributions.
Beyond that, what is Team USA giving up to help the nation recover and protect the financial future of our children and grandchildren?
Good question, Chuck Todd.
Not such a good answer, Mr. President.