How many is too many? When not to vote
Monday, August 31st, 2009By KW
First, I like Tim Kessler. He’s been a GF&P commissioner longer, I believe, than any other commissioner in history.
He pays attention. He works to balance sportsmen and landowner concerns. He listens to state biologists but isn’t afraid to depart from the company line.
So, liking him made it harder to write a story questioning whether it was appropriate for Kessler to propose and vote in support on an increase in the state shooting preserve pheasant limit, from 15 a day to 20 a day for more than half the seven-month preserve season.
Kessler, see, is the “landlord” of a hunting preserve operated by his brother, George, on Tim’s land up near Aberdeen. So he’s not the operator, but he’s pretty close.
On that same issue, preserve operator Mike Authier of Vivian abstained. Was that necessary? Should Kessler have abstained, too? Good questions, I think, and ones that should be discussed further by the comission.
Potential conflicts of interest are common on the comission, where landowners vote on issues that hurt or benefit landowners and hunters vote on issues that hurt of benefit hunters. So is this specific issue different? I’m not sure.
But it’s interesting, especially since one commissioner felt uncomfortable enough to abstain.
The preserve limit itself is a separate can of worms. I have mixed feelings. I can’t see why anybody would want to shoot 20 rooster pheasants in a hunt. And I agree with those who fear it casts hunting in a bad light.
But preserve owner Paul Nelson makes a fair point in pointing to 20–a-day lmits on spring snow geese, and past state limits in the regular pheasant season that ranged up to 10 per day.
I think the key issue on preserves is that they kill wild birds, about 20 percent of their annual kill, according to their records. And some of those birds are shot outside the regular season, and presumably in bag limits that exceed the regular three bird kill allowed in the regular season.
To address that, Kessler proposed an the commission pass an amendment that make the 20-bird bag revert back to 15 at the end of the regular ringneck season. Still, it’s an interesing question.
I don’t have a a for-sure answer to either that one, or the commissioner conflict issue.
Do you?














